Discussion List for campus-based and allied personnel working to end gender-based violence on campus.

["Raguet, Marissa (MDH)" <>]

Thanks so much Kate for saying that! I too was confused that the studies were portrayed as having strongly conflicting findings, because when I read them they seemed to primarily offer complementary findings rather than opposing findings. I was actually surprised how similar my takeaways from the studies were, given that the studies used such different methodologies. And so I thought- am I reading these wrong? Grateful to hear that others are thinking the same thing!

 

Both studies raise some key questions that call for further research, and the limitations of these two studies should be addressed through new studies. The PreventConnect webinar was super helpful and participants raised so many great questions that I hope future research can help provide evidence to address.

 

Marissa

 

Marissa Raguet

*Gender Pronouns: she/her/hers

Project Coordinator

Sexual Violence Prevention Program
Injury and Violence Prevention Unit
Minnesota Department of Health
PO Box 64882, St. Paul, MN 55164-0882
Phone: 651-201-5424  FAX: 651/201-5800
e-mail:
Website: www.health.state.mn.us/injury/topic/svp

 

From: Lonna Davis [mailto:]
Sent: Wednesday, September 16, 2015 9:46 AM
To: Kate Rohdenburg <>
Cc: Irvine, Mahri <>; ; ;
Subject: Re: Lisak, Hopper, and Tracy response to Swartout, et. al. research claims

 

Thanks Kate, I find your comments very WISE ; )

Sent from my iPhone

Apologies for typos

On Sep 16, 2015, at 10:15 AM, Kate Rohdenburg <> wrote:

Thanks Mahri (and the many who are thinking about this)

I just want to add – I’m particularly troubled about the way that these two groups of researchers and findings have been set up as a debate/conflict, It seems purposefully misleading and so strange considering the values of this field. I can’t help but notice all of the ways that both findings give us a little more insight, have happened at different times and places, have made decisions about the framing and presentation of their data, and may add richness rather than cancelling each other out. The opportunity to hear from many researchers learning about perpetration and having the benefit of responses to the insightful and complex questions that I saw running across the chat box during yesterday’s webinar would be so much more useful.

 

I’m happy to help in whatever way I can be useful to help organize the different kind of professional development and conversation that’s being proposed.

 

Kate Rohdenburg, Program Director

Program Center at 38 Bank Street, Lebanon NH

24-hour Crisis Line: 1-866-348-WISE

Office: (603)448-5922 * Fax: (603)448-2799

www.WISEuv.org * www.facebook.com/WISEuv

<image001.jpg>

 

From: Irvine, Mahri []
Sent: Wednesday, September 16, 2015 9:25 AM
To: ; ;
Subject: Lisak, Hopper, and Tracy response to Swartout, et. al. research claims

 

Dear All,

 

(Apologies for cross-posting!)

 

For those of you who attended the Prevent-Connect webinar yesterday, featuring several researchers discussing much-hyped research claims about serial and one-time rapists, you might be interested in checking out the response from David Lisak, Jim Hopper, and Allison Tracy.

 

I found their response to be immensely helpful, and I truly appreciate them taking the time to not only carefully and methodically explore the data sets, but to also make sure that they explained their concerns in language that is easy to understand.

 

Because the Swartout et. al. research claims have been so heavily promoted by various news sources and organizations lately, I hope that everyone will have the opportunity to also learn about the response from Lisak, Hopper, and Tracy. (I know that I will be sharing this response very, very widely.) In fact, it seems to me that we should have a national webinar featuring their response in the very near future, so that as many people as possible are able to hear about their concerns and interpretations of the data. And, after Lisak, Hopper, and Tracy finish their peer-reviewed publication, I hope that NSVRC will publish a “research translation” report of their work, just like the one that NSVRC produced for the Swartout, et. al. article.

 

Sincerely,

Mahri

 

Mahri Irvine, PhD

IU Statewide Sexual Assault Education and Prevention Specialist

Indiana University - Purdue University Indianapolis

Walker Plaza 220

719 Indiana Avenue

Indianapolis, IN 46202

317-274-2501 (office)

317-278-0948 (fax)